Admissibility of illegally obtained evidence in a civil case follow this and additional works at. Hi fellow law students, i have uploaded lecture notes in pdf format containing the ebook notes for the subject law of evidence for llb and ba. Silence, confessions and improperly obtained evidence peter. Evidence law admissibility of evidence essays law teacher. The common law is arguably inherently unfair and the outlined position that evidence can be excluded if the prejudicial effect of it outweighs its probative value is accepted, but lord diplocks belief that the court has no interest in how evidence was obtained builds a false economy without a doubt, and is a considerable danger to human. This thesis considers the law on confessions, illegally improperly obtained evidence and entrapment under the police and criminal evidence act 1984. Nov 30, 2015 professor michael stockdale gives general overview of the role of the law of evidence, including confessions and improperly obtained evidence.
Otherwise, admissibility of improperly obtained evidence may undermine the main functions of the. Section 8 of the act stipulates that evidence may be excluded if it was illegally or improperly obtained. New trends in illegal evidence in criminal procedure. The admissibility of real evidence in the light of the. Improperly obtained evidence in the commonwealth sage journals. This important new book examines in some detail the law relating to confessions, unlawful evidence, and the right to silence in the police station. Admissibility of illegally obtained evidence in a civil case. Exclusion of improperly obtained evidence in civil proceedings. English cases dealing with illegally or improperly obtained evidence had accepted this view with. A trial judge has a discretion to exclude evidence illegally obtained, to discourage unlawful conduct by the police. This is an extract of our opinion evidence document, which we sell as part of our laws 307 law of evidence notes collection written by the top tier of university of canterbury students. Home university study tools law improperly obtained evidence.
This thesis examines article 697 of the rome statute, which creates an exclusionary rule for improperly obtained evidence at the. Mitchell v r 20 nzca 251 improperly obtained evidence evidence obtained in search under tainted warrant admitted. Whilst it will be for you to decide, in each particular case, whether or not the evidence falls into the category of illegally obtained evidence, this ethical assistance is designed to assist in any situation in which it appears that the evidence has, indeed, been so obtained. An exception allowing evidence obtained by law enforcement or police officers who rely on a search warrant they believe to be valid to be admitted at trial. Critically evaluate the importance of judicial discretion to exclude evidence, with particular regard to evidence unlawfully, improperly or unfairly obtained and consider how, if at all judicial discretion has been affected by the human rights act 1998. The use or admission of unlawfully obtained evidence in a particular case may render the proceedings unfair as a whole. The south african law of evidence forms part of the adjectival or procedural law of that country. A reply to professor mishkin 1966 33 v chi lr 719, 752. An examination of the caselaw suggests that there is room for greater critical. Exclude improperly obtained evidence to deter police from engaging in similar behavior in the future to obtain evidence externalreliability approach admit the evidence in court so long as it is reliable and disciplineaddress the misconduct in a different arena but external to the proceedings and unrelated to the defendant, separation thesis.
About improperly obtained evidence in angloamerican and continental law. Below is a sample legal opinion professional advice. Admissibility is always decided by the judge and all relevant evidence is potentially admissible, subject to common law and statutory rules on exclusion. There is no allembracing statute governing the south african law of aspects. In this context, we look among other things at whether courts should admit improperly obtained evidence, and we ask what the privilege against selfincrimination is and whether it can be justified. Exclusionary rule definition, process, examples and cases.
Justia us law us case law us supreme court volume 367 mapp v. In this respect your attention is drawn to gc11 and gc. Admissibility and exclusion of evidence in criminal. English laws traditional approach to the admissibility of improperly obtained evidence is currently being rethought in response to a range of domestic and international pressures. Evidence study aids exam study guide research guides. Evidence obtained illegally in civil and family proceedings. It has been accepted for inclusion in law faculty publications. The fair trial rationale for excluding wrongfully obtained evidence. The article then looks to developments in the lecturer in law, school of law and government, dublin city university 1 people a.
S 78 pace 1984 expressly preserves the common law discretion. The law library of victoria service is totally digital while the supreme court library is temporarily closed. The admissibility of evidence in nsw is primarily governed by the evidence act 1995. In chapter 8 of the book dennis examines the question of how the law of evidence deals with evidence that has been obtained by illegal or unfair means. The exclusion of improperly obtained evidence in greece.
The nzsc on improperly obtained evidence at last hamed v r 2011 nzsc 101 is online, although in redacted form. Formatted to be memorised and contains all the necessary information to achieve a 2. Confessions, illegallyimproperly obtained evidence and. It should be noted that the rules on the exclusion of improperly obtained evidence in ireland have been constructed almost exclusively by the courts. An understanding of the principles of legal evidence will be invaluable to any wouldbe advocates or litigators. Silence, confessions and improperly obtained evidence. Improperly obtained evidence flashcards in university law. Illegally or improperly obtained evidence is evidence obtained in violation of a persons human rights or obtained in breach of the law or procedure and it would be unfair or unjust to use it. The exclusion of improperly obtained evidence at the. Having examined the exclusionary rule in the common law system, dennis found out that even logically relevant evidence, which was obtained improperly, shall be forbidden for admissibility.
Admissibility of improperly obtained evidence law essay. Section 5a of the evidence act is only inclusionary and not exclusionary in nature since it merely allows the courts to admit evidence which is admissible under common law and is not expressly or impliedly excluded by the act. Peter mirfield also looks closely at the principles behind this branch of the law. Until that time, the common law provided that any relevant evidence, no matter how it was obtained, could be entered into criminal proceedings as proof. Evidence obtained illegaly or improperly proposed section. In defence of australias discretionary approach evidence act cdp seminar unsw law school wednesday 2 march 2016 introduction 1. Even if the improperly obtained evidence were reliable, considerations of reliability are no longer determinative given that the charter has made the rights of the individual and the fairness and integrity of the judicial system paramount. An exception permitting evidence improperly obtained to be admitted at trial if the. I would like to begin by respectfully acknowledging the traditional owners of the land on which we meet, the gadigal people of the eora nation, and pay. Mar 02, 2016 illegally or improperly obtained evidence.
Xxx xxx is charged with racially aggravated affray, two counts of. Below is a sample legal opinion professional advice written for a man charged with a series of criminal offences. However, the court made the significant observation that the police officer is more likely to behave properly if improperly obtained evidence is liable to be viewed with care and caution by the judge. To make the law of evidence as clear, simple and accessible as possible. As you will learn, much of the law of evidence involves rules of admissibility.
Illegally obtained evidence is that which is collected in contravention of nsw law. The focus of the module is on the law of criminal evidence, but many of the concepts and principles are also valid in the context of civil litigation. This thesis examines article 697 of the rome statute, which creates an exclusionary rule for improperly obtained. This is chapter 16 of principles of criminal evidence by a zuckerman. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Improperly obtained evidence is legally admissible whether it is by prosecution or defence. Topics covered include preparing and presenting evidence, crossexamination, and the procedure for admitting and excluding evidence. Unlawfully and unfairly obtained evidence law teacher. Kerri mellifont although much has been written in australia on the rule and discretions to exclude such evidence, little has been written on a particular species of such evidence, that is, evidence which is derived. The author tries to present the most significant principles of the exclusionary rule in the common legal system, using the examples of the relevant cases. It is a fundamental principle of english law, and a right under the european convention of human rights that in a criminal trial, the prosecution. There is a detailed discussion of the case law and the principles which underlie that case law as well as a detailed discussion of the principles and policies which underlie the relevant statutory. Ohio at large in the fifty states 1962 3 duke law journal 319. Nov 17, 2014 below are the primary exceptions to the exclusionary rule.
On 26 october 2016, the supreme court released its decision in marwood v commissioner of police 2016 nzsc 9. The subject was taken up by the law commission on its own. Admissibility and exclusion of evidence in criminal proceedingsoverview. This is not to say that the law of evidence is clear and simple in all respects. Illegally or improperly obtained evidence legal issues. The admissibility of real evidence in the light of the constitution of. Illegally obtained improperly obtained admissibility exclusion discretionary approach public policy concerns deterrence rationale disciplinary rationale evidence act 1995 cth, s8 australia. Recommended citation depaul college of law,admissibility of illegally obtained evidence, 5depaul l.
Evidence study aids exam study guide research guides at. The law in this chapter, written in 1989, is inevitably out of date but it remains a powerful exposition of key principles. The question of admissibility of evidence is whether the evidence is relevant to a fact in issue in the case. Discusses privilege against selfincrimination, privilege concerning improperly obtained evidence, scientific evidence, and demonstrative evidence. Law of evidence exam notes written from textbooks and lectures for illegallyimproperly obtained evidence.
Evidence act 1995 sect 8 exclusion of improperly or. This decision required the court to determine whether new zealand courts have jurisdiction to exclude improperly obtained evidence in civil proceedings and, if so, whether the jurisdiction should be exercised on the facts of the case before it. Nov 30, 2012 the common law is arguably inherently unfair and the outlined position that evidence can be excluded if the prejudicial effect of it outweighs its probative value is accepted, but lord diplocks belief that the court has no interest in how evidence was obtained builds a false economy without a doubt, and is a considerable danger to human. Common law system foundations for excluding evidence. Common law system foundations for excluding evidence obtained illegally or unfairly and the relevant case law keywords. The statutory provision however permits a court to exclude improperly obtained evidence. The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the pdf sample above, taken from our laws 307 law of evidence notes. The exclusion of improperly obtained evidence at the international criminal court. In the english tradition illegally or improperly obtained evidence was not a. The defendant has a right to a fair trial and therefore his trial team must consider issues surrounding the admissibility of unlawfully and unfairly obtained evidence. Pandeyjohnson v r 20 nzsc 5 judicial directions about evidence which may be unreliable classes of potentially unreliable evidence question whether. This is the first book to offer an extensive cosmopolitan, crosscultural insight into the perennial controversy over the use of improperly obtained evidence in criminal trials. The first article outlines briefly the background of the south african law of evidence and the handling of illegally obtained. Advice on an application to stay proceedings as an abuse of process.
In the common law doctrine the law of evidence is determined as the law, which. This can be examined by looking at the position in common law s78 of pace and the abuse of process procedure. At common law it was long established that trial judges enjoy a general discretion to order the exclusion of technically admissible evidence if they feel that its prejudicial effect exceeds its probative value see e. Faculty of lawnational university of singapore nussingaporesingapore. The exclusionary rule was established at the federal level in 1914 by the united states supreme court in the case weeks v. My dear minister, i am forwarding herewith the ninetyfourth report of the law com mission on evidence obtained illegally or improperly.
1146 1062 1353 1255 602 189 606 739 664 69 1463 888 494 1208 1394 317 1067 957 1018 1532 509 1217 228 1157 51 652 1003 1401 634 1480 693 565 727 1010 1471 169 671 941 734 520 1453 988 8 875 1312 99 810 1136